American Spirits: the Fallacy of a Green Cigarette

All things considered, cigarettes are probably one of the most difficult products to market as “earth-friendly”, right up there with gas-guzzling SUVs and disposable drink cups. Cigarette butts are unsurpassed as the most littered item in the world (trillions per year). Growth and curing of tobacco contributes massively to deforestation in developing countries. With this in mind, how could it be possible to have a believable green ad campaign as a cigarette company? Somehow, American Spirit is managing to do just that.

It starts with the packaging. Every pack of American Spirit cigarettes has the word “Natural” and depicts a Native American smoking on the front of the carton. Some packs also contain an insert with advertising claims similar to the ones made above. Before knowing anything about the company, consumers are bombarded with green implications. According to Terrachoice’s “Seven Sins of Greenwashing”, this falls right in line with the sin of “Lesser of Two Evils”. Much like an SUV being marketed as fuel-efficient, the notion of an environmentally friendly cigarette is somewhat ludicrous — from an outside perspective. However, to a regular smoker, this kind of advertising can be harder to see through; in fact, it actually seems to be working.

Let’s look at the claims that American Spirit makes as a company. Being 100% wind-powered is a great achievement, as are the other environmental advancements the company is making. But there is absolutely no information about the actual product — take away the brand name and these “eco-friendly” attributes could be for any company. Just to recap; NO claims are made about the environmental sustainability of American Spirit cigarettes, and yet they are considered to be an environmentally friendly alternative to Marlboro or Camel. It’s amazing how deceptive an ad campaign can be without actually telling any outright lies.

Fortunately, regulation against cigarette advertisements on TV and radio have made it difficult for these ads to reach mainstream consumers. However, cigarette companies are at an advantage because they have a captive audience: in fact, many smokers will actually turn to American Spirits instead of quitting because they feel that they are a better alternative. (My main motivation for researching this company was a coworker telling me that American Spirits don’t cause cancer because they’re organic). Is it true that overall, American Spirit cigarettes are better for the environment? Yes, fractionally. But all the hand dryers and hybrid cars in the world can’t cover up selling the most littered product on the planet.

Jessica Daniels


2 thoughts on “American Spirits: the Fallacy of a Green Cigarette

  1. This was a really interesting product to use. I never would have guessed that a cigarette company would be able to successfully sell themselves as being “green”, but even I found myself impressed with their claims (and I like to think that I know better).

    I might be misinterpreting the sin “worshiping false labels”, but I think the image of the Native American smoking would make that sin applicable as well. I think having that image goes a long way in giving the impression of a “natural” product, given our cultural and stereotypical impressions of Native Americans.

    Josh Maddux


  2. Cigarettes are a great example of something that is horrible for the environment but with deceitful ads, try and convince us otherwise. You’re post really drove that point home. I did not know that cigarettes supplemented the human pollution like it does! It is always important to look past the tricks of a company trying to sell a “green” image and analyze the products. I really enjoyed reading this post thanks!

    Zach Werner


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s